Scraped by Hand vs. Machine: Is There a Big Difference?

Some hand scraped floors aren’t actually scraped by hand but are done by machines. On a floor that is genuinely scraped by hand, every plank will have unique markings. An artisan who does a lot of planks is likely to use a similar technique on the planks to create a cohesive look, but they shouldn’t all be the same. With hand scraped wood floors, it is important to pay attention to placement because every piece is deliberately done.

With machine scraping, the floors have a more repetitive look, and if you pay attention, you will be able to find patterns. It doesn’t look as pleasing to the eye and can be hard to put down.

So, let’s explore the differences between hand-scraped and machine scraped to see what’s right for you.

Pros and Cons Of Hand Scraped Flooring

The reason many people pick hand scraped flooring is because they are so durable. If you have children, dogs, or you just like to host people and wear high heels, you need a floor that is durable and won’t show (or get) every nick, scratch, and dent. With hand scraped flooring, those types of marks actually add more character to the flooring. You get to “make it your own,” so to speak.

One reason some people don’t like hand scraped flooring is that they can be really hard to install for first-timers. You will have to work methodically and follow all of the instructions. You can’t just haphazardly skip something because it seems silly.

The good news is that there’s a lot of value in hand scraped flooring. It lasts a long time, looks great in all types of homes, and can improve the resale value of your home. Still, it can cost a little bit more than other types of flooring. You’ll have to weigh the cost for yourself, but most people who take the plunge don’t regret spending a little extra on this type of beautifully unique flooring.

Hand Scraped or Distressed Hardwood?

Sometimes, people will say that a hand scraped wood floor is a distressed hardwood floor or that a distressed hardwood floor is a hand scraped wood floor. These terms actually cannot be used to describe the same flooring.

Distressed flooring is different. Distressing uses dings and dents to make the floor look like it has been used and worn over a long time. It gives a home an “aged” feeling. Distressing is often done with a machine, and if you look closely enough, there is typically some kind of pattern.

Distressing also isn’t as popular as it used to be. It is sometimes used in commercial and retail applications to fit the theme of a bar or restaurant.

Hand scraped floors, as you have learned by now, have more subtle markings that are deliberately left by an artisan. The look is much softer and professional. If you are going for a rustic feeling, it will give you that, but without some of the wormholes and other elements that can make distressed flooring a bit of an eyesore to most people.

Are Hand Scraped Wood Floors Hard To Keep Clean?

If you are a neat freak, then you might worry that hand scraped wood floors are hard to keep clean or that the scraping traps in dust and debris. While this can happen if you allow your floors to go months and months without cleaning, it isn’t likely.

To clean your hand scraped wood floors, you want to use an approved hardwood cleaning flooring product. There are plenty of options out there, including options that are better for the environment and the people in your home.

You do want to avoid any of the DIY floor cleaners that involve vinegar, as that can dull the finish on hand scraped wood floors.

When you get your wood floor, it’s best to order a few more so that you can keep some extra planks to test your cleaning supplies on when you go to clean. If you switch cleaners, always test it on those planks to see if it will have an impact on the finish or the overall appearance of the flooring. Be sure to test over the normal wood and the scraped wood.

To clean your hand scraped wood floor, use a good quality broom or microfiber mop (dry) to remove all of the excess dirt and debris from your floor. If you have children or pets, you may want to do this regularly just to avoid buildup, but it isn’t necessary.

Then, use the hardwood floor cleaner of your choice in a bucket of warm (not hot) water. Dip your mop into the bucket, wring it out, and use the slightly dampened mop to clean the floor. It’s the same process as other wooden floors. The only concession you’ll need to make is that you can’t use a steam mop or a wet mop.

What Rooms Does Hand Scraped Hardwood Work Best In?

There are many rooms where hand scraped hardwood flooring works. Many people will get it in their kitchens because it creates that rustic feeling that so many people like. Since it is easy to clean and doesn’t show dents, it is perfect even if you drop spaghetti sauce or a heavy pan (it happens, no judgment here!). 

Hand scraped hardwood is great for living areas as well. High-traffic areas tend to get worn down quickly, particularly if you have pets and kids, so this flooring option is perfect for living rooms, dining rooms, entryways, mudrooms, and more.

If you want to have hardwood in your bedroom, hand scraped flooring also works there. In fact, we think it works extremely well in almost any room. It even works as a wall covering to make a focal point!

Hand Scraped Hardwood Flooring Has Earned Its Time in the Spotlight

Hardwood flooring is popular, and it is highly unlikely that we are going to go back to carpeting anytime soon. Hand scraped hardwood is a hit because it allows for a unique feel to your home, and it gives it that personal touch that other types of flooring simply can’t provide. You won’t find another home with the same type of scraping your home has, and being unique is a great feeling!

Sources:

How to Hand-Scrape Wood Floors | Old House Online

Here are the Main Pros and Cons of Hand Scraped Hardwood Flooring | Epic Home Ideas

What is Handscraped Hardwood Flooring? | Angi

Leave a Reply